Two Letters to Judge Eaton

For reasons that will be obvious, these letters were partially re-written to conceal the identity of the client.

Paul D. Carrington

University of Michigan Law School

Ann Arbor, Michigan 48104

September 16, 1971

Hon. Joseph Eaton

United States District Court

Southern District of Florida

Miami FL

Dear Judge Eaton:

I write in regard to Isaac Rosenthal who will come before you for sentencing next week.

I have known Isaac since 1956.  At that time, his father Myron (Mike) was in the Army, as was I.  We were both stationed at the Aberdeen Proving Ground.  We both lived with our families in a building erected to house married soldiers.  �Ike� was four when our second child was born there in 1957.  Partly because his father was a Captain and I was a Private First Class, we were not close at that time.

But when my wife and I moved to Ann Arbor in 1965, we were pleased to discover the Rosenthals as neighbors.  Ike sometimes played wiffle ball or touch football with our children.

In 1967, Ike was expelled from Ann Arbor Pioneer High School because he wore his hair in violation of the school�s grooming rules.  As a friend, I appeared before the Ann Arbor School Board to argue that the grooming rules were too severe.  It happened that on the day of the school board meeting, a colleague took me into his bank while he cashed a check.  The Presidents of the United States were pictured on the wall.  I observed that only four of them would be permitted to attend Pioneer High School.  I called that situation to the attention of the school board, and they rescinded the grooming rules.

Despite my success as his lawyer, Ike refused to return to school.  He was an irrationally angry young man.  Ann Arbor is the sort of town in which very smart children sometimes grow up too fast.  Ike at fourteen was a strenuous anti-war activist and deeply embittered by what he perceived to be the bovine indifference of the community to the brutalities occurring in Vietnam.  He could not stand it that his parents (both of whom are tightly wound professional people) continued to go to work, keep house, visit with friends, and indeed go on living while there was Vietnam on the tube every night.

Not long after the school board rescinded the grooming rules, Ike moved out of his parents� house.  I encountered him on the street a little later and saluted him; he gave me a hostile glare but did not otherwise acknowledge me.  We then heard that he was living in a garret or a garage somewhere around town.  Time passed, and his parents received word that he had moved to upper Michigan.  A year passed.  Somehow, he sent word to his father that he was living in Amsterdam.  Another year passed.  We heard that the police were looking for him in Amsterdam.  Still later, it was rumored that he was now in Morocco.  His grandmother went to Morocco to look for him in the dens and brothels of Marrakech, but she did not find him.

Then last spring, Mike called me to say that he had heard from Ike.  �Great,� I said.  �But,� he said, �he is in the custody of the United States Marshal.  He has been busted for smuggling.  He wants me to send him a lot of money so he can try to bribe a federal officer or judge to let him out.  Should I do that?�  Of course I derailed the absurd guardhouse idiocy, and found him a lawyer, an alumnus of this law school, and on his advice, Ike has pleaded guilty.

Meanwhile, however, he was allowed to return to Ann Arbor on bail.  Mike made him come see me.  He was still as hostile as he had been that day on the street, but was at least submissive enough to ask my advice.  I told him I had none, really, but that I did know an old judge Lincoln in state court in Wayne County who had told me that he had sentenced 25,000 children in his years on the bench, and that his iron rule was never to send one to training school if he had a job or if he was making progress in school.  �Maybe, Ike,� I said, �you might get a lighter sentence if you found work.�

I do not know that my words made an impression, but he did find a job supervising newsboys for the Ann Arbor News.  This was only part-time work, so he enrolled in the high school completion program at Washtenaw Community College.  That did not fill his time, so he took a night shift job working in a tool and die shop.  The daughter of the owner of the shop took a shine to him, and she is now his steady company when he is not working or studying.  He now smiles.  He smiles a lot.

It seems to me there is a good chance that Ike is now able to take care of himself and will do so.  I don�t know if you subscribe to Judge Lincoln�s iron rule, but this might be a very good time to apply it.

I hope these thoughts are useful.  Best wishes.

Sincerely yours,

/s/ Paul D. Carrington


 

Paul D. Carrington

Duke University School of Law

Durham, North Carolina 27708-0362

September 16, 1999

Hon. Joseph Eaton

United States District Court

Southern District of Florida

Miami FL

 Dear Judge Eaton:

 This is my second letter to you.  The first was written twenty-eight years ago today.

Perhaps you recall my first letter.  I enclose a copy to refresh your recollection.  You of course did not answer it.  But, as his father reported the sentencing hearing to me, you asked Ike if it was true that he had trouble with authority.  He grunted an affirmative answer.  You acknowledged that you, too, sometimes had trouble with authority.  You then stated that the pre-sentencing report told you that you ought give him at least five years of hard time.  You then stated that his sentence was indeed five years.  However, you said, �Just to show that I too can defy authority, I hereby suspend the whole sentence.  If you get caught speeding in the next five years, you will begin with five years in the federal penitentiary and then they can worry about the speeding ticket on top of that.  Go make a life for yourself, Mr. Rosenthal, and then you can forget the last four years.�

You may not know that Ike a few weeks later married the girl friend mentioned in my previous letter.  She was an undergraduate at Michigan.  Ike finished his high school course, and enrolled at Eastern Michigan University in nearby Ypsilanti.  After a year of all As, he transferred to the University of Michigan where he compiled a spectacular undergraduate record.  He went on to do graduate work at the University of Chicago.  His record there earned him a faculty appointment at Berkeley.  He is now a professor of cell biology at that distinguished university.  He and his wife have two children who prosper in school.

I salute your wisdom.  I am informed that if Ike had come up for sentencing in 1999 that the judge would have had no authority to suspend the sentence, and that he would have spent as much as twenty years in the federal penitentiary.  What a tragic waste!

Best wishes.

Sincerely yours,

/s/ Paul D. Carrington

A gracious response to the second letter was received from the elderly Judge Eaton, who expressed the hope that his descendants might ever read about his decision in Ike�s case.  I share his hope.

mailto:pdc@law.duke.edu index.htm

Tomtop|

IT Support| POS label| System Integration| Software development| label printing| QR code scanner| wms| vending machine| barcode scanner| SME IT| it solution| rfid tag| rfid| rfid reader| it outsourcing| IRLS| inventory management system| digital labelling| barcode label| Self Service Kiosk| Kiosk| Voice Picking| POS scanner| POS printer| System Integrator| printing labels| Denso| inventory management| warehouse management| Business service| vending| mobile app development| terminal handheld| printer hong kong| thermal printer| thermal label printer| mdm| mobile solutions| mdm solutions| mobile device management|

banner| Backdrop| Bannershop| Ebanner| Eprint| foamboard| hk print| hong kong printing| Printing| backdrop| print100|

electric bike| e bike| electric bicycle| electric bikes for adults| electric tricycle| electric trike| folding electric bike| mid drive electric bike| electric fat bike| fat tire electric bike| best electric bike|

Hong Kong Office Rental| office for lease| office leasing| office building| Commercial Building| Grade A Office| Rent Office| office for sale|

Central Plaza| The Centrium| LHT Tower| China Building| AIA Central| Crawford House| Exchange Tower| AIA Tower| World Wide House| One Kowloon| The Gateway | One Island South| Jardine House| Millennium City | Exchange Square| Times Square | Pacific Place| Admiralty Centre| United Centre| Lippo Centre| Shun Tak Centre| Silvercord| The Center| Mira Place| Ocean Centre| Cosco Tower| Harcourt House| Cheung Kong Center|

private school hong kong| English primary school Hong Kong| primary education| top schools in Hong Kong| best international schools hong kong| best primary schools in hong kong| school day| boarding school Hong Kong|

Mailchimp|​​​​​​​ Hubspot| Sendinblue| ActiveCampaign| Aweber| benchmark| SMS|